Ingredients

1 c plus 2 T ketchup

1 c water

1/3 c cider vinegar

1/4 c packed brown sugar

1 T minced onion

1 T chili powder

1 T black pepper

1.5 t molasses

3/4 t celery seed

1/2 t smoked paprika

Preparation

Combine everything in a 3 qt saucepan; bring to boil over med heat. Reduce heat; simmer about 25 min, until slightly thickened.